One hallmark of the Lyford Cay Club is its embrace of timelessness and tradition, which includes their dress code:
- No denim clothing, no cargo pants, no torn clothing, no large logos (graphics)
- All white for tennis, croquet, and padel (shoes included)
- Shoes are required in most areas of the club, unless at the beach
- Jackets for gentlemen at night (for non-wedding occasions)
- Collared shirts are required for all dining areas (except the beach shack)